Difference Between Abstinence and Harm Reduction (With Table)

Treatment for substance disorders especially addiction can be resolved by these two methods: abstinence or harm reduction. Patients and families may wonder, “Which technique performs superior?” while selecting a therapy provider. That’s a tough one to answer since each ideology has its own set of advantages. As a result, it’s critical to be very well in both ideologies before deciding which strategy is best for you.

Abstinence vs Harm Reduction

The main difference between Abstinence and Harm reduction is that Abstinence focuses on the complete elimination of both alcohol and drugs. On the other hand, Harm Reduction focuses on the damages and tries to eliminate them. So, if defined in simpler terms, Abstinence focuses on the root of the cause whereas Harm Reduction focuses on the disease spread by that root.

The eliminate the addiction and enroll in addiction therapy is abstinence. Patients must entirely refrain from all alcohol and drugs in an abstinence-based strategy. People with drug use disorders, according to experts, are unable to adequately manage their usage in a way that does not lead to substance abuse and detrimental consequences. The patient should be valued and respected as an element of a strong addiction recovery strategy. Addiction should be dealt with by a comprehensive team of experts.

The harm reduction paradigm focuses upon the effects caused by consumption and addiction of drugs and alcohol and works on eliminating them. This paradigm acknowledges that substance use is complicated and that abstinence may not be the best option for everyone. Its goal is to avoid drug-related fatalities, infectious illnesses, comorbidity, and other negative health outcomes. Harm reduction strives to repair the damage caused by folk’s substance use among themselves and society.

Comparison Table Between Abstinence and Harm Reduction

Parameters of
Comparison
AbstinenceHarm Reduction
Focuses OnEliminate the root
Works on harms and
side-effects.
Treatment TypeCriminalizationDecriminalization
MethodologySeparationIntegration
ViewHomogeneousHeterogeneous
Working UnitStigmatizationNormalization
EffectEliminates the causeReduces the harm
ReflectsDeny and deter
Freedom and
Responsibility
Believes InComplete problematicPartial Problematic

What is Abstinence?

The full discontinuation of substance abuse usage is referred to as abstinence. This method has long been hailed as the most integrated and coordinated technique to overcome addiction. Abstinence has long been the standard way of breaking drug or alcohol addictions, well before addiction was diagnosed as a medical problem.

The fundamental principle is that addiction is a sickness that is both unintentional and primary. It can be described and diagnosed. Addiction is a chronic and progressive condition. While there is no treatment for this condition, it may be controlled.

While some persons are more or less driven to seek addiction treatment for addiction, this has no bearing on the therapy’s success.

Because addiction encompasses a wide range of a person’s life, comprehensive treatment that addresses the physical, intellectual, social, and spiritual components is the most successful. The addict should be entitled to protection as part of a great drug rehabilitation strategy.

Addiction should be dealt with by a multidisciplinary team of experts. Among the most important aspects of treatment is indeed the core psychologist. They also said they would ideally share the patient’s demographic and maybe be a former drug addict as well. Self-disclosure, mutual identity, group solidarity, and shared culture would all benefit from this.

According to research, the most appropriate treatment for addiction combines a twelve-step approach and supportive social.

What is Harm Reduction?

Harm reduction strives to reduce the harm caused by people’s opioid use to themselves and others. Harm reduction began in the United Kingdom in the 1980s in reaction to an alarming rise in HIV incidence among drug injectors. The key goals of the UK’s 2017 Strategic Plan are also to reduce illegal and other hazardous drug usage while also increasing recovery rates.

Its goal is to avoid drug-related fatalities, invasive illnesses, comorbidity, and other negative health outcomes. The method encourages the use of needle and syringe systems (NSPs) to assist lessen the negative consequences of drug addiction.

Scotland, Wales, and Ireland each have their national drug plans, each with several number harm reduction goals. Medicinal therapies can also be used to help in harm reduction. There’s a whole variety of medications that can assist lessen the desire to use and, as a result, total usage.

Education on possible dangers and how to mitigate them may influence on these habits. It’s essential to recognize that interventions aiming at preventive care of a particular habit must have a different focus than those focused on prevention and treatment in groups of teenagers who have already developed the behavioral.

This necessitates thorough consideration of the approach’s intended target group as well as the environment in which it is implemented.

Main Differences Between Abstinence and Harm Reduction

  1. The main difference between abstinence and harm reduction is that abstinence works on eliminating the addiction whereas harm reduction works on reducing the harms caused by addiction.
  2. Abstinence is a separate process whereas harm reduction is an integrated process.
  3. Abstinence can completely diminish the addiction whereas, in the case of Harm Reduction, only harms are reduced, the chances for it to come back are still there.
  4. Abstinence reflects deny and deter whereas Harm Reduction reflects freedom and responsibility.
  5. The abstinence working unit is stigmatized whereas the harm reduction working unit is normalized.

Conclusion

Families seeking drug addiction therapy for a significant being must evaluate the scope and severity of the problem honestly. Because addiction is a lifelong illness, the only way to keep it in remission is to follow an abstinence-based treatment plan.

Abstinence-only therapy is considered to be somewhat helpful if a person is misusing illegal or prescribed substances. Similarly, if an individual has inflicted severe harm to his or her own or others’ lives, abstinence-only therapy is the best step in this process.

References

  1. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09687630410001723229
  2. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0955395910001337
  3. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11414-013-9318-2